Cameron Metrejean Reviews Wind River

Critic Cameron Metrejean reviews the film Wind River starring Elizabeth Olsen and Jeremy Renner.This project is supported by We support, develop, & help create Lafayette artists.
Remember back when I said I loved finding untapped indie films but that it had been a while since I found one? Well, Wind River might be that indie film, though with a little star power to help it along.

When the body of a dead girl is found in the snowy Wyoming Native American reservation, out of town FBI agent, Jane Banner (Elizabeth Olsen) teams up with the town’s veteran game tracker, Cory Lambert (Jeremy Renner) to investigate the murder.

If there’s one thing to take away from this films it’s its realism. Much like last year’s Manchester by the Sea, there are many times where you feel like the interactions you’re seeing are out of everyday life. But where as Manchester kept us at an at-home family drama Wind River is a mystery story in a setting unfamiliar to many. Having gone through the occasional mystery craving, I can safely say that mystery movies are very easy to screw up, often times working in some nonsensical plot points. But Wind River infuses its realism with its mystery. It feels natural. It never tries to throw in some random convoluted twist. It sticks to the bare facts and clues and they follow it from there. With that, the struggles feel natural. There is no asshole boss or an explicit bad guy trying to damper the case aside from the assailants they are trying to track down. In the wrong hands, this could have very easily turned into a buddy cop drama. And sure, Cory and Jane have their differences but at no point are they ever strictly at odds with each other. The same goes with the supporting characters they interact with. We don’t get any characters they are completely hostile or completely friendly with. Even when moments of violence come up they burst onto the screen like a Falcon Punch because that’s exactly how these kinda of surprises would feel like in real life. No preamble of suspenseful music or warning of a tonal change, just raw energy.

“Wind River isn’t a film that minces words. It gives the grisly details that it thrives upon because, as the movie says at one point, “You can’t steer from the pain or you’ll rob yourself.” It’s a wonderful character driven story that doesn’t skimp when it comes to plot. ”

Share this Post

Jeremy Renner sure loves playing a sharp shooter, and he should considering he’s good at it. He delivers a nice turn for himself as a man who wrestles with the memory of his daughter dying much like the dead girl their investigating. Elizabeth Olsen is an actress that has slowly been making her way into the hearts of critics. This performance adds a different flavor from her past works like Silent House and Martha, Marcy May, Marlene where she played young girls in way over their heads. As Jane Banner, she plays a more than capable enforcer that’s just out of her element but still trying to be taken seriously. She has more than made her own image separate from her Full House sisters.

Given its setting, this is a movie that needed to feel like it has at least some connection to its culture. The topic of the Native Americans who still live there, as well as the harsh environment and terrain, are brought up multiple times and it always feels sincere about these topics. There is clearly a lot of empathy for people who struggle with the problems portrayed. It’s been a while since I’ve seen a film that so effectively got you to feel its environment. Maybe I was just in a cold screening but the snowy landscape came alive to me as well. We get a lot of calm pastoral moments with nature that all make for an engrossing experience. Even during the more energized shoot out scenes, the camera really knows how to get you feeling like you’re there experiencing it. Much of that praise goes to writer/director Taylor Sheridan who has used his previous two films Sicario and Hell or High Water to create this “American Frontier” trilogy.

The movie isn’t totally without its flaws however. As stated, this movie works in some of the Native American heritage and naturally a few moments talking about the culture run the risk of being preachy. One particularly painful scene features a character cutting themselves in a state of despondency. Heartbreaking, right? Even more heartbreaking is that no one even tries to stop them from hurting themselves. They play it off sort of like “What’s the point? This is our life.” Also here and there some line readings are a particularly low to the point that I wanted subtitles on the screen to understand. Some people may not gravitate toward the pensive tone but I do think there are just enough moments of levity to keep it from becoming monotonous.

Wind River isn’t a film that minces words. It gives the grisly details that it thrives upon because, as the movie says at one point, “You can’t steer from the pain or you’ll rob yourself.” It’s a wonderful character driven story that doesn’t skimp when it comes to plot.

Share this Post

Cameron Metrejean — an actor, writer and film critic who loves to review films through the lens of an actor.

Cameron Metrejean is a local actor, film critic, writer and jack of all trades. You will find him around town in front of the lens and behind.

He is a passionate cinephile with a unique voice forged through industry experience.

Find Cameron
  • download
  • 6a00d83451b36c69e201bb0789dd6a970d-600wi

bckstry favicon.ico

bckstry helps creatives develop a career through their art.


Started in 2015 as a grassroots effort, bckstry (backstory) is focused on supporting young creatives in the Lafayette, LA and Acadiana region through mentorship, job training and opportunities, We have grown into the community voice for all modern artists.

Our organization is comprised of filmmakers, dancers, graphic designers, musicians, photographers and creative professionals all focused on establishing a sustainable career through their art.

Our unique mentorship and job training program has successfully trained over 30 community members who have gone on to get jobs in their respective industries. is here to train the next generation of creatives while supporting our modern artists in order to develop a sustainable arts community. If you’re looking for a creative professional group, come join us and let us help you get to where you want to be.